Glass v5 properties intermittently null when security applied

Glass Mapper version 5 caches data more aggressively which is beneficial most of the time as it improves site performance. More information on the new caching features can be found here. In order to speed up performance some checks which Sitecore normally does are not performed when an item is returned from the cache. Usually this will not cause any issues but there could be potentially serious issues when security is involved. For example consider below scenario:

  1. User 1 has access to a certain item, but User 2 does not. Security is applied through the regular Sitecore security mechanisms.
  2. User 2 visits the site first, and Glass loads the model. This model has a link to the item which user 2 does not have access to, therefore this link is empty. It will get cached this way.
  3. Now user 1 comes and the model will be returned from cache. Since it was initially cached for user 2 the link is still empty whereas user 1 should be able to view this.

Notice that this behavior is not deterministic, i.e. if user 1 would have hit the site first then the item would be loaded. It would also be loaded for user 2 if that user visits later. This can cause intermittent and hard to find issues especially if the code was working correctly prior to upgrading. Good news is that fixing this is straightforward!


It is recommended to leave the cache on as much as possible to take advantage of the performance improvements.

Is there is an issue with a certain link which can point to an item where security might be applied, then caching can be turned off through an attribute like this:

[SitecoreType(Cache = Glass.Mapper.Configuration.Cache.Disabled)]
public virtual Link SecureLink { get; set; }

Perhaps this issue only occurs when retrieving items through the SitecoreService or MvcContext. In these cases the cache can be turned off explicitly in the call like this:

T val = mvcContext.GetDataSourceItem<T>(x => x.CacheDisabled())

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s